Wednesday, March 26, 2014

          USPTO: Creating Transparency in Ownership of Patents & Applications

          Sample alt tag.
          "To put it simply," testified Prof. Robin Feldman, "shell games and hide-and-seek rarely make for an efficiently functioning market." (Photo from House Committee on Energy & Commerce's Subcommittee on Oversight & Investigations).

          The US Patent & Trademark Office held its hearing on Creating Transparency in Ownership of Patents & Patent Applications today at UC Hastings.

          Testimony provided by Robin Feldman, Professor of Law & Director of the Institute for Innovation Law at UC Hastings is reprinted here and highlights of key points are summarized below: 

          "To put it simply," writes Feldman, "shell games and hide-and-seek rarely make for an efficiently functioning market."

          • As the secondary market for patents expands, society must ensure sufficient information so that the market functions efficiently.
          • Information is a great leveler; it can help address the imbalance between how cheap it is to launch a patent demand and how expensive it is to determine whether the demand has merit.
          • Understanding the money flow as well as the formal control structures will be essential for understanding who is really in control.
          • Allowing vast networks of hidden behavior has the happy coincidence of preventing regulators from observing behavior. Public and private antitrust actors, as well as securities regulators, should be able to connect the dots that can reveal troubling patterns of behavior.

          Commending the USPTO for its revised proposals and noting that they are “a much needed effort to strike at the heart of transparency problems,” Professor Feldman suggested tightening three areas of the proposed rules that could allow patent holders to evade the regulation. (The full testimony provides examples of current patent owners and how the rules might fail.)

          • First, the antitrust thresholds referenced in the rules are too loose a sieve to catch all of the relevant information.
          • Second, the language related to “hidden beneficial owners”—that is, those who try to avoid detection—should be strengthened. Explicit reference to securities law disclosure concepts could ensure that the rules cover not only today’s evasion techniques but also tomorrow’s.
          • Third, the rules require updated information at only a few times during the twenty-year term of the patent. Occasional information does not provide the robust information necessary for an openly functioning market. 

          "In short, patents are imbued with public interest by virtue of the fact that they are a government grant, bestowed only for purposes enshrined in the Constitution itself. As with the trading of public securities, the trading of an asset imbued with the public interest must be sufficiently regulated to ensure proper functioning of that trading market."


          Media Contact

          Alex A.G. Shapiro
          Director, Communications & Public Affairs
          UC Hastings College of the Law
          Office: (415) 581-8842
          Cell: (415) 813-9214


          Go to News Archive

          Share this Story

          Share via Facebook
          Share via TwitterShare via EmailPrint Friendly Version

          Other Recent Stories/ RSS

          Friday, October 21, 2016

          Innovative gift from tech startup accelerator Hackers/Founders supports UC Hastings Startup Legal Garage

          “It's very often that startups push the boundaries and definitions of laws written decades or centuries earlier," says Hackers/Founders CEO Jonathan Nelson. "Being able to face these issues with a law school that's doing cutting-edge work is invaluable.”
          Tuesday, October 18, 2016

          Tenderloin Community Benefit District Appoints UC Hastings 3L to Board of Directors

          Improving the sidewalks means more than cleaning services, says 3L Peter Stevens, tenants rights advocate and proud Tenderloin resident.
          Monday, October 10, 2016

          2L Briana Desch spearheads new Tenderloin Community Outreach Board for ASUCH

          Student task force dedicated to establishing relationships with the Tenderloin community.
          Monday, October 10, 2016

          Manuel v. City of Joliet: Don’t forget “unreasonable” in the Fourth Amendment

          Analysis by Professor Rory Little
          Friday, October 07, 2016

          Kevin King ’15 finds his voice arguing before the First District Court of Appeal

          "I came to law school to become a social justice advocate and now I’m armed to build a better tomorrow." - Lawyers for America Fellow Kevin King, Class of 2015
          Go to News Archive